Compromise ruins relationships.
is what I learned while waiting at the dentist's office yesterday. and i absolutely agree.
i was reading an article about married couples who were at the breaking point of their relationships. these were people who had married for love but either because of an accumulation of small daily stresses or the big decisions of whether or not to have a child were tearing them apart.
Example 1: Mary and Todd
They had 3 children from 8-13 years of age. and every morning was a battle between them to get their kids ready for school. Todd wanted them to learn that actions had consequences, so if they didn't wake up on time with their alarm clocks or missed the school bus, they had to walk to school. Mary wanted them to just get to school, so she would personally wake them up even if they had overslept and drive them to school if they missed the school bus. The kids took full advantage of their parents' arguments and ended up sleeping in and more often than not getting a ride to school.
Both Mary and Todd thought that theirs was the right way. And both felt like they were getting the short end of the stick when it came to the morning routine.
Example 2: Chris and Jill
This was Chris' 2nd marriage and Jill's 1st. Chris already had a 14 year old daughter from his first marriage. Jill had no children of her own. Jill wanted to have kids. Chris, seeing how distraught his daughter was over her dad having another kid, didn't. They were at an impasse. Jill even said that if she knew Chris would have changed his mind about having kids after they were married, she wouldn't have married him in the first place.
In argument over argument, Chris and Jill became more and more polarized. Chris listed all the reasons why they shouldn't have kids. Jill listed all the reasons why they should have kids. If either gave an inch, the other would use it as ammo for their own cause.
Solutions:
I thought the therapist was brilliant. She basically recommended that both couples try the other side for a week at a time and see what happened.
For Mary and Todd, she told them that ONE person should be in charge for a week and the other should just observe. For Chris and Jill, she said that they BOTH should talk about the pros of having kids once and then the cons of having children another time.
And apparently both worked.
For Mary and Todd, they each saw how some of their own routines worked and didn't. Mary saw that by driving the kids to school, the kids would try harder to be late. Todd saw that actually waking up the kids made the whole morning routine less stressful and more efficient.
For Chris and Jill, they may not have come to an agreement, but they were able to see another aspect of their spouses. Rather than the bastard who won't have kids and the incredibly selfish bitch, they saw the husband who was torn between love for his daughter and wife and they saw the wife who wanted a child of her own and was hurt her husband didn't want to share such an important experience.
They say give a little, take a little. But, it might be better to give a lot and take a lot. If one person is in New York and the other in California, it doesn't make sense to live in Montana. Both would feel like they had compromised, both would feel like the other owed them in some way, both would feel like they had been screwed. Rather, it might work better if they both lived in New York, then it's clear who gave/took and when it comes to the next big decision, it'll be on the other person's terms.
Clearly one reason the therapist sessions worked was because she forced the partners to really step into the other's shoes. It's easy to criticize when you're just watching someone. It's harder to bitch when you actually had to stand up for them/actually tried to do things their way for once because you end up criticizing yourself.
If you think of one partner as black and the other white, where they meet shouldn't be just a mix of the two and plain gray. Maybe, it should look more like a checkerboard but when you step back and look at the big picture, it still turns out to be one happy solid color.